Maximizing Conception Rates Using Fresh, Cooled, or Frozen Canine Semen
Robert V. Hutchison, DVM
Animal Clinic Northview, Inc.
Since the American Kennel Club's recognition of litters conceived from frozen semen in 1981 and the subsequent acceptance
of fresh chilled semen, practitioners are being asked more frequently to assist clients with maximizing conception rates using
these breeding techniques. The gratification one feels when successful is one of the great rewards in veterinary medicine.
The basis of fresh chilling and freezing semen is energy conservation within the sperm cell so that the semen can be shipped
or used at a later date. The drawback to these methods is that even though some energy is conserved, enough energy is used
to shorten the sperm cell's life. Fresh semen is thought to live four to six days in-utero. The freshly ejaculated sperm life
allows for successful breeding when the bitch exhibits standing and acceptance of the male, even though in many cases the
timing is four to six days before the prime fertilization period of the mature ova.
FRESH CHILLED SEMEN
Fresh chilled semen uses energy as it is cooled to 40'F (4'C) and eventually re-warmed to body temperature. The life in-utero
of spermatozoa having experienced the chilling and subsequent warming process is 24 to 72 hours, necessitating a more precise
manner of ovulation timing and breeding. When sperm is frozen for future use, it is eventually stored at-322'F. (-180'C).
This extreme temperature preserves a sperm cell indefinitely but not without stress and energy output. The thawed spermatozoa
have a maximum life span of twelve to 24 hours after insemination into the bitch. The ultra-short life span makes success
with frozen semen only possible with precise mapping of the bitch's estrous cycle with definitive detection of the LH release
and the subsequent time of ovulation. When a veterinarian receives a fresh chilled sample, the package should immediately
be opened. Attention should be paid to the "impression of coolness". The ice packs should be at least cold, if not still frozen.
The package containing the semen should be removed from the packaging material (usually newsprint). The tube should contain
the extended semen in a liquid state. Unfortunately, occasional mishandling by the shipping company or by the shipper placing
the semen package in a non-pressurized compartment of the airplane will cause the sample to arrive frozen. The freezing kills
the sperm cell and renders the sample useless.
One drop of the sample should be placed on a warmed microscope slide. The rest of the sample should be refrigerated. Allowing
the chilled sample to warm to room temperature only allows the sperm cells to speed up, using precious energy and shortening
their life span.
As the drop wanns on the slide, the accompanying paperwork with the semen collector's evaluation of the semen quality,
time of collection and post-collection motility should be studied. The semen drop is then analyzed and compared to the collector's
In many cases, the semen will appear to be non-motile. However, as the semen drop warms gradually side to side motility
becomes noted. The continued warming eventually shows the cells to have achieved a normal forward progression. If no motility
is noted after fifteen minutes, the sample is most likely non-viable. If this occurs the collector of the semen should be
contacted to determine, if possible, the cause of the semen's demise. In other cases where only partial semen recovery is
noted, the inseminator must use judgment based on the connection of the semen, estimated total spermatozoa numbers and the
percent recovered. It may also be necessary to alter the insemination method to that of an intra-uterine deposition of the
fresh chilled sperm to further remove sperm cell stress and to aid its arrival at the fallopian tubes.
It is recommended that the refrigerated fresh chilled sample not be warmed to room temperature or body temperature before
insemination. Having the sample in the uterus as it warms makes maximum use of the conserved energy. All fresh chilled semen
samples are handled in a similar manner. However, many different commercial companies sell packaging kits and extenders. One
should always read their instructions for any specific handling recommendations.
Frozen semen requires even more precise handling than fresh cooled semen. Frozen semen will usually be shipped in a dewer
with nitrogen vapor keeping the sample frozen rather than with actual liquid nitrogen in the container.
When the shipper arrives, the tank will be in a protective shell. The shell should be opened and the plug pulled (not twisted)
from the nitrogen tank. Visible vapor should be seen assuring the recipient that the tank is charged properly and that the
sample is still frozen. If vapor is noted the plug should be replaced until the time of insemination. If no vapor is seen,
an attempt should be made to ascertain that the sample is still in a proper frozen state. This can be accomplished by grasping
the cane that holds the semen and raising it to the mouth of the dewer. If the sample is thawed, the semen will not be viable
and a replacement sample should be obtained if possible.
If the sample is frozen, the person that shipped the sample should immediately be contacted to discuss the tank status
and determine if some liquid nitrogen should be added to the dewer to assure that the sample will remain frozen until time
for the insemination.
Canine semen is frozen in two different forms, 1) pellets and 2) straws. Both are extremely successful in achieving conception;
however, it is essential that the doctor doing the insemination follow the thawing instructions precisely. Most thawing techniques
require that the person using the semen have a form of warm water bath available. A form describing the semen's quality, both
pre and post thaw should have accompanied the shipment. These values can be used to judge the quality of the thaw before insemination.
Each individual that freezes canine semen has a specific manner of handling and thawing their product. There is no room for
TIMING OF INSEMINATION
Historically, methods of timing the estrous-cycle of the bitch such as color of discharge, swelling of the vulva and flagging
of the tail allowed breeders to get bitches bred, but using these signs, in many cases, created more confusion than answers.
Veterinarians and breeders have used vaginal cytology, a rough gauge of estrogen level, to "pinpoint" the time of ovulation.
Vaginal smearing at best gives a retrospective view of the cycle with diestrus, day one, occurring six days post-ovulation.
However, vaginal smearing does not allow prospective timing other than giving information as to when other testing needs to
begin. Vaginal cytology is not useful by itself in timing fresh cooled or frozen semen. The same can be said of vaginoscopy,
a visual method of evaluating vaginal fold swelling and crennulation that equivocates with estrogen rise and fall.
The serial testing of serum samples from the bitch for either progesterone testing or luteinizing hormone (LH) testing
will give the veterinarian a prospective view of the ovulation, ova maturation and the prime fertile period for using the
fresh cooled or frozen semen.
The release of progesterone from the ovary and its subsequent rise to an average of two to three ngm corresponds with luteinizing
hormone release from the pituitary gland and signifies the start of the ovulatory process. The rise of progesterone is greater
than five ngms (five to eight ngm) indicates that ovulation has occurred. Once the ovulation day has been confirmed, fresh
cooled semen inserninations in two to three days or frozen
semen insemination in three to four days can be planned. Progesterone, not being specific, can be tested for by many methods.
Numerous elisa kits for in office use are currently available. Progesterone, can also be evaluated by radio-immune assay (RIA)
by many human and veterinary laboratories.
Progesterone rises and continues to stay elevated for approximately two months in the bitch, whether she is pregnant or
non-pregnant. The bitch needs to be tested every 48 hours to anticipate the prime breeding time.
When using the progesterone elisa kits, negative features include that hemolyzed blood samples will give lower than normal
results. If the elisa kits are not handled properly or warmed to room temperature, an artificially high result will be recorded.
Ideal testing for progesterone level would include screening with the elisa kits, but obtaining RIA progesterone numbers,
to define the exact day of ovulation and the corresponding breeding time.
Cortisol release needs to be a concern when doing progesterone testing as stressed bitches may have a delayed period between
a rise of two to three ngm/ml and the time that the progesterone rises greater than five ngm/ml. Some bitches under stress
have been shown not to ovulate even after a rise of progesterone above two ngm. It is essential if using progesterone testing
to confirm that the bitch has risen above five ngm/ml and has indeed ovulated.
Luteinizing hormone (LH) is a species specific hormone arising from the pituitary gland. The release of the hormone spikes
over a twelve to 24 hour period. The release of the LH triggers ovulation in 48 hours, allowing for a final meiotic division
of the ova and shedding of the polar body (approximately another 48 hours) before the ova can be fertilized. An accurate evaluation
of the LH spike can give the veterinarian and breeder four to five days anticipation of the prime insemination dates and reasonable
confidence as to the maximum chance of conception.
Unfortunately LH assays are not easily available for canines at the time of this writing. As LH is species specific human
laboratories cannot run this assay. An immuno chrornatinographic testing kit is currently available for in office use. The
test, status LH (International Canine Genetics, Inc., Malvern, PA 19355 USA), uses a wicking paper with a reaction test zone
and is run with four drops of serum.
The test develops a distinct colored line (red) when the serum LH rises above one ngm/ml. When the line appears one would
anticipate prime breeding time to be in four to five days with fresh cooled semen and five to six days with frozen semen (the
variation based on anticipated sperm life in utero).
Negatives to the LH test are that daily samples must be drawn (even greater than 24 hours between tests may miss the LH
rise). The cost of daily testing, owner compliance and veterinarian availability for testing every day has created some problems
for this testing method. Serum samples that are hemolyzed or lipemic also affect the testing results. LH testing is especially
useful in bitches previously tested by progesterone assay that did not conceive or that showed irregular progesterone levels.
Artificial insemination has been a commonly used procedure in small animal reproduction. However, the advent and common
usage of canine frozen and fresh cooled extended semen has refocused clinicians' attention to more precise methods of semen
delivery to the bitch's reproductive system the shortness of spermatozoa life. Loss of sperm cell energy in fresh cooled extended
semen and frozen semen has necessitated the development of new methods of semen delivery in the bitch. Frozen semen especially
benefits from techniques by passing the cervix and the cervical mucous and being deposited directly into the uterine lumen.
Two techniques of artificial insemination are routinely performed and are amenable to the veterinary practitioner dealing
with canine reproduction. The two techniques to be described are vaginal insemination and the surgical intra-uterine deposition
When proper timing of the estrous cycle is performed on the bitch and proper semen handling and delivery is accomplished,
conception rates should rival those of natural breeding. Delivery technique problems such as improper placement of the insemination
rod, improper semen placement or semen damage due to mishandling have convinced many dog breeders and veterinarians that artificial
inseminations are only used as a last ditch desperate measure.
The estrous cycle for the bitch should be monitored using serum progesterone assaying or some other reliable manner to
ascertain that ovulation has occurred. Semen motility is evaluated as previously described.
The bitch is positioned with her rear elevated either manually or on a breeding ramp. Care should be taken to avoid pressure
on the bitch's abdomen. The semen is drawn from the collection tube through an insemination rod of proper length to reach
the cervical os. It is important that the semen be deposited at the entrance to the cervix so that the semen can be drawn
into the uterus. With gloved hands the veterinarian gently inserts the insemination rod through the lips of the vulva at an
upward 45-degree angle. The rod is gently passed over the pubis and along the dorsal median fold until it is parallel with
the lumbar spine and localized in the area of the cervix. If resistance is encountered the rod should be gentlytwisted or
withdrawn a short distance then readvanced.
When the insemination rod is properly positioned the semen should be gently inseminated. The syringe is then removed from
the rod. It is not necessary to push large amounts of air into the rod nor is it normal to get semen backflow if the rod is
properly positioned and the bitch is in the estrus stage of estrous. Excess air "bubbling" through the semen is detrimental
to the fragile plasma membrane of the head of the spermatozoa.
The bitch is then "feathered" digitally for one minute. The rear of the bitch is maintained in an elevated position for
six minutes to allow gravitational feeding of semen to the anterior vagina. The bitch owner is instructed to confine the bitch
or restrict her activity for one to two hours post-insemination.
SURGICAL INTRA-UTERINE DEPOSITION OF SEMEN
A technique for surgical insemination in the bitch was first described in 1974. The intrauterine deposition was initially
used to increase poor conception rates in the use of canine frozen semen. Since that time, surgical deposition of semen into
the uterus has become a routine technique used in numerous situations encountered in canine reproductive medicine.
A) Frozen Semen -Due to the lack of spermatozoa energy buffer chemical makeup, or cervical resistance the conception rates
from cryo-preserved canine semen have been historically low when used with a vaginal insemination. Surgical deposition into
the uterine lumen has resulted in conception rates equal to those from natural breeding.
B) Fresh Cooled Extended Semen -Shipment of semen rather than shipping bitches has become common place due to shipment
time, and spermatozoa energy depletion. Numerous clients have chosen surgical semen insemination for their bitches in hopes
of increasing conception rates. C) Bitches with Suspected Uterine or Ovarian Disease -The ability to access uterine and ovarian
health at breeding time is advantageous to clinicians presented with bitches with histories of reproductive failure or problems.
D) Giant and Toy Breeds -Individuals on the extreme ends of size have historically been recognized for conception difficulties.
The ability to overcome anatomical barriers and inseminate directly into the uterus has increased litter numbers and relieved
client frustration. E) Males with Lowered or Compromised Spermatozoa Numbers -Little work has been done in the canine to definitively
define minimum semen parameters necessary for conception by directly depositing the semen into the uterus and bypassing the
cervix and vaginal vault. Conception can possibly be achieved with lesser sperm numbers and lesser overall semen quality.
A pre-surgical evaluation is performed on the bitch. Anesthetic induction consists of coning smaller individuals with gas
anesthesia (i.e. isoflurane). Larger bitches may require an injection of a standard short acting anesthetic (i.e. propofol)
to achieve relaxation for intubation and maintenance with gas anesthesia.
The bitch is prepared in the same manner as a bitch undergoing an ovariao-hysterectomy. The ventral abdomen is clipped
and the bitch is placed in the surgical theater in dorsal recumbency. Prepping of the surgical site is done in a routine manner.
The abdomen is draped in preparation for the surgery.
A four to six centimeter incision is made midway between the pubis and the umbilicus. The incision is made in the skin
subcutaneous fat through the linea alba. The uterus is identified and elevated to the surface through the incision. The uterus
is draped with a saline moistened laparotomy pad as the semen is prepared for the injection procedure.
A volume of semen varying between .5 ml and four ml is prepared for insemination. If the volume is greater than 4 ml, the
semen should be centrifuged for five minutes. The supernatant is decanted and disposed. The semen pellet is gently re-suspended
with the remaining supenate or with a semen extender. The semen to be injected is gently drawn into a six-ml syringe through
an insemination rod. The rod is removed and a 22 gage, 1/4 inch needle is attached to the syringe.
The surgeon inserts the needle into the lumen of the uterine body at a 45-degree angle with the bevel of the needle up.
The semen is slowly injected into the uterus. The semen should flow easily with obvious distention of the uterine horns. If
the injection cannot be achieved or is difficult, the needle should be repositioned. A saline moistened gauze is held over
the injection site after the needle is withdrawn. After one minute, the gauze is removed and the uterus is replaced into the
abdomen. Closure of the fascia, muscle, subcutaneous tissue and skin is routine.
The bitch's rear is elevated as she recovers from the anesthesia. The intra-uterine pressure during the surgical deposition
of the semen may cause mild backflow through the cervix into the vaginal cavity, this appears to be of no concern. If the
surgeon has doubt as to the semen being placed in the uterine lumen, a post-operative vaginal smear will confirm spermatozoa,
if the technique has been performed properly.
Dr. Robert V. Hutchison, who earned his DVM from The Ohio State University, is currently a co-director of the Animal Clinic
Northview, Inc., an American Animal Hospital Association certified, ten doctor veterinary practice. Recognized internationally
for work with canine frozen semen and canine reproduction, Dr. Hutchison produces approximately 150 frozen semen litters yearly.
Dr. Hutchison is the Director of the International Canine Semen Bank of Ohio, and a member of the American Veterinary Medical
Association, the American Animal Hospital Association, the Society for Theriogenology and the Ohio Veterinary Medical Association.
He has served on the Continuing Education Committee, the Ethics & Grievance Committee, the Program Committee, and the
Racing Committee of the OVMA, as well as being a leader of the Lorain County Veterinary Medical Association and the Canine
and Feline Fertility and Sterility Group.
He currently serves as on off-quarter advisor for College of Veterinary Medicine students interested in small animal theriogenology
from The Ohio State University, Virginia Tech, Purdue University, Tufts University, Michigan State University and Auburn University.
In addition, Dr. Hutchison has authored articles on canine reproduction in various breed journals and magazines, made television
appearances and been featured in such publications as Canine Chronicle and AKC Gazette.
An internationally recognized speaker on canine and feline infertility, reproduction, whelping and pediatrics, Dr. Hutchison
also finds time to serve on the Board of Directors of the Samoyed Health and Research Foundation, study the fertility proteins
in canine semen with a grant from the AKC Endowment Fund and work as a consultant for Veterinary Forum and the Veterinary